Recaps

Wrexham 2-1 Southampton, 19 Sep The room split down the middle, and the bigger half was right

Wrexham 2-1 Southampton, and for once the league's favourite scoreline was also the correct one. Inside a week where 140 of you called it to the goal and the panel scraped a draw with the crowd.

Wrexham 2-1 Southampton

There is a particular kind of afternoon where the Fearless Forecasts board stops looking like a prediction league and starts looking like a very polite argument. Southampton at home was one of those. Of the 675 predictions in before kick off, 40% of you had the win, 37% had Southampton, and the 23% in the middle were presumably the ones enjoying themselves least.

Three percentage points. That is what separated a home win from an away one in the collective head of nine hundred-odd people, and it is the tightest the room has been all season.

How the league called Southampton at home. The bar is what we thought, the stamp is what happened.
How the league called Southampton at home. The bar is what we thought, the stamp is what happened.

The bigger half came out on top, which means 270 of you took points off the afternoon. And then there is the number that makes this week genuinely unusual.

140 of you had it to the goal

Twenty-eight different scorelines got backed for this match. The most popular of them, by a distance, was 2-1. And 2-1 is what happened.

That almost never occurs. The crowd's favourite is usually a hopeful average, the scoreline that offends nobody, and the real result turns up down in the teens of the ranking. At West Ham not one person out of 685 had it, because nobody sane writes 0-6. This time the obvious answer was the right one.

The six who held 2-1 the longest, measured from their last edit to kick off.
The six who held 2-1 the longest, measured from their last edit to kick off.

The prize for nerve goes to Gorsefield13, who put 2-1 on the board on 5 September, 13.7 days before kick off, and then never touched it again. Not through the West Ham result, not through a fortnight of everyone else fiddling with their picks. Just left it there, correct, waiting. You can see the full table for where that has left them.

As for us

Ah.

What the four of us managed, and how the panel stacks up against the league.
What the four of us managed, and how the panel stacks up against the league.

Andy called 2-1 and took five points, and we are all delighted for him in the way you are delighted for a colleague who has just been promoted over you. Tim had 3-2, which got the result and two points. Liam went for a Southampton win. Rhys had a draw. Neither of them scored anything at all.

Here is the uncomfortable arithmetic. On this fixture the four of us averaged 1.75 points a pick against your 1.52, so we shaded it. Across the whole season it is 0.75 to your 0.67. Nine counting fixtures in, the entire accumulated wisdom of a podcast panel amounts to being fractionally less wrong than a crowd of strangers. And if you remove Andy's 2-1 from this week, the three of us left over averaged 0.67 on the day, which is exactly where the league is.

Beating us is free, and a worrying number of you are doing it.

The table is refusing to settle

DrewStu is still top on 19 points, and has been for a while now, but Dolly's Mixture is dead level on the same 19 and split only by exact scorelines. That is the season's real question in miniature: DrewStu has three exact calls to their two, and when two people are this close, the tie-breaks stop being trivia and start being the thing.

Behind them it moved quite a bit. Rhody Red went from 39th to 7th on the back of a single exact call, 10 points to 15. Jbk climbed from 29th to 6th, Upthewella from 26th to 5th, and Wrexham WV from 22nd to 9th. One correct scoreline is worth more than a fortnight of being sensibly close, which is either the best or the worst thing about this format depending on how your week went.

The hottest run in the league is four correct results in a row, shared by Pengwernred11, Crappybara and liveinhopedieincaergwrle. One more each and they pick up Purple Patch, which you can find alongside the rest on the badge list. This week handed out 270 Southampton badges for calling the result and 140 for the exact score, plus 231 Racecourse Reads for a first correct call at home.

Two things worth a minute of your time

The match ratings board for Southampton is open and almost empty, because it only went live at full time. Twenty-one of you marked the squad after West Ham and 36 did it after Burnley, and those numbers turn into something genuinely interesting once enough people weigh in. Go and give the eleven a mark out of ten. It takes about forty seconds and it is a great deal more satisfying than shouting at a highlights package.

And if the big board feels like a long way to climb, there are now eight private mini leagues running, with 26 players in one. Anyone can start one and invite their mates. The winner is whoever tops their own table, not the national one.

Next

Derby away, Saturday 10 October, after the international break. 365 of you have already got a pick in and 76% are backing the win, with 2-1 the most-backed scoreline again. Make of that what you will.

Eleven new players joined this week, taking the league to 912 across 52 countries. If you have not started, it takes a minute, it is free, and you get to spend your Saturdays proving four men with microphones know less than you do.